Men and women can experience depression in different ways, and although they also share many common signs and symptoms, a better understanding of the differences may help those with depression
How Girls and Boys Differ in Depression
Over 300 million individuals around the world have depression. Sometimes co-occurring with other mental health conditions (e.g., anxiety, bipolar disorder, substance abuse), depression is characterized by low mood, loss of interest and pleasure, and major changes to sleep and appetite, among other potential symptoms. The type and timing of depressive symptoms depend on many factors, one of which is gender.
A recent study of gender differences in depression, published in the April issue of the Journal of Youth and Adolescence, describes depressive symptom trajectories in males and females from late childhood to adolescence and young adulthood. Previous research has found similar rates of depression in both male and female genders prior to puberty—though some findings suggest boys may be slightly more likely than girls to experience depression. During adolescence, however, the rates diverge. In this period, young women are almost twice as likely to be depressed as young men; women will continue to have a higher likelihood of meeting the criteria for depression in their adult years.
The recent study examined how depressive symptom trajectories diverge in adolescence; such information can be helpful in informing healthcare providers, parents, and teenagers themselves about the potential challenges of this developmental period.
Study of trajectories of depression in male and female adolescents
Data for the present investigation came from the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC) in the Bristol area in England, which—beginning in the 1990s and with an initial cohort of almost 14.000 infants—has been regularly collecting data on the participating children and their parents (using questionnaires and clinical visits).
The authors used eight waves of data from ALSPAC. Participants in these waves were between ages 11 and 22 years. Overall, researchers analyzed 40,000 measurements—from 9,300 participants for whom data on sex and at least one assessment of depressive symptoms was available.
Depressive symptoms were evaluated using a measure called the Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire (SMFQ). The SMFQ contains 13 items which assess an individual’s mood in the past two weeks. Sample items include “I felt lonely” and “I felt miserable or unhappy.”
Based on the results of multilevel growth-curve modeling, researchers observed significantly different population-averaged trajectories of depressive symptoms for males and females, as shown in the figure below.
As you see from the graph, except between ages 10 and 11 years, female adolescents had higher depressive symptoms than males.
The maximum level of depressive symptoms occurred at age 20.4 years for males and age 19.6 years for females. The fastest increase in depressive symptoms occurred at age 16.4 years for males and 13.5 years for females.
Why do male and female depression follow different trajectories?
As we have seen, the trajectory of depressive symptoms increase for both genders during adolescence. Why?
Perhaps because teenagers face numerous changes during this developmental period (e.g., puberty, school transition, forming friendships). What is less clear is why depressive symptoms in young men and women follow different trajectories, with women experiencing more depressive symptoms and an earlier peak.
One possible explanation for this difference is the earlier puberty in females compared to males. For instance, previous research has shown that early age of menarche (first menstrual cycle) is associated with greater depressive symptoms:
“Hormonal changes and transformations in brain structure and function foster a disjuncture between systems involved in the regulation of arousal and emotion and those involved in the cognitive modulation of behavior,” with the imbalance between emotion regulation and stress reactivity creating a “fertile ground for emotional arousal” (p. 1430-1).
This increased reactivity and stressor responsiveness in adolescent girls may result in greater anxiety and depressive symptoms. Therefore, early puberty is linked to an “earlier age of higher depressive symptoms,” and this might “set an individual up for a higher trajectory which takes longer to recover from. This could explain why females have higher trajectories compared to males” (p. 823).
Depression interventions
What are the implications of the different trajectories of depressive symptoms in male and female adolescents? It is important to identify depression early, and interventions targeting female teenagers may need to start earlier than those targeting males. Parents, schools, and clinical services need to be informed that on average, female adolescents—compared to male adolescents—experience not only a more rapid increase in depressive symptoms at an earlier age but also more depressive symptoms overall. Awareness and earlier interventions may help improve depressive symptoms and reduce the likelihood of depression later in life.
8 Differences Between Boys and Girls
Curious about some stereotypical behavior you’ve noticed in your little one, or wondering what to expect if you’re expecting a son or daughter? It turns out that gender differences aren’t that significant — though there are a few that start in the womb and continue through childhood.
In terms of anatomy, differences between boys and girls can be pretty obvious. But when it comes to brain development, the disparities between the two sexes are actually pretty small. It turns out that behavior and development have more to do with life experiences than they do with gender — and in order to reach his or her full potential, your cutie needs lots of attention and encouragement from the get-go. Read on to learn more about where (and how much) gender plays a role in your son or daughter’s development.
Understanding Emotions
True or false: Females tend to be more in tune to people’s emotions. True! After reviewing over 100 studies, researchers concluded that even in infancy, girls are better at figuring out people’s emotions based on their facial expressions. Another study found that baby girls would rather look at faces than mobiles, while the opposite was true for boys. While the reading-faces skill begins at birth, both nature and nurture play a role — the difference in ability is more than twice as pronounced in grown-up men and women as it is in little ones. What’s behind the difference? Experts think it’s because girls are taught to express their feelings, while boys are encouraged to suck it up.
Takeaway tip: As moms everywhere know, baby boys aren’t any less sensitive, so teach your son the words for his feelings (“You’re mad because you can’t reach the rattle”) as you talk to him.
Spatial Skills
One reason boys tend to outscore girls on the math portion of the SAT is that they may have an advantage when it comes to spatial skills — or the ability to solve problems involving size, distance and the relationship between objects. Although social expectations for male mathletes probably play a big role in this gender difference, studies have found that the difference does appear very early in life. Studies suggest that boys as young as 3 to 5 months old can visualize how an object will appear when rotated, while girls of the same age can’t.
Takeaway tip: Give your girl building blocks, talk about numbers, play ball with her, and, when she’s old enough, introduce her to kid-friendly computer, video and smartphone games that focus on targeting objects (now, there’s a great excuse to play Angry Birds).
Toy Preference
Babies don’t distinguish between “boy” and “girl” playthings — in fact, studies show (and many parents know) that baby boys love dolls. So it’s plausible to think that boys like trucks and girls like tea sets because society tells them to. But while gender-specific marketing and peer pressure in preschool can influence a tot’s taste in toys, there’s good evidence that there’s also something innate about preferences for certain playthings, starting around age one. In fact, girls who are exposed to higher-than-normal levels of sex hormones, including testosterone, in the womb show an above-average interest in cars and trucks. And in a study of monkeys, male primates chose wheeled toys over plush toys, while females liked both. What does that mean for humans? You can expect your daughter to be more open than her brother about what she plays with — usually starting around kindergarten.
Takeaway tip: Widen your little boy’s toy horizons by offering all sorts of playthings instead of sticking to the stereotypical stuff.
Physical Activity
Go to any playground and you’re bound to see more boys running, playing ball and jumping — and that difference in physical activity may start in the womb. After reviewing 46 previous studies, Canadian researchers concluded that baby boys are bigger wiggle worms than baby girls — they squirm more on the changing table, get restless in the stroller and crawl over longer distances, for example. You may not notice the difference in your boy and girl babies, though, say scientists: While the average boy doesn’t move around much more than the typical girl, the most active kids are almost always boys, and the least active, girls.
Takeaway tip: Get both sexes moving with plenty of active playtime — from dancing indoors to playing chase outside.
Aggression
Boys are more physically aggressive than girls even before they turn two, according to studies. Scientists say prenatal testosterone is a big factor, and that boys are subconsciously playing at something they’re statistically more likely to do in adulthood than girls: get into physical confrontations. But girls aren’t angels, either: Toddler girls kick, bite, and hit three times more than either gender does by the time kids enter grade-school (by then both sexes have been socialized so they use their words more than their fists).
Takeaway tip: Little boys and girls need to learn limits, so be firm about enforcing the “no hitting” rule.
Walking
Although many parents say boys reach gross-motor milestones like sitting up, crawling, cruising, and walking earlier than girls, some pediatricians swear the opposite. But both camps are wrong: Study after study shows that there are no significant differences between boys and girls when it comes to gross-motor development. Both genders usually start walking sometime between nine and 16 months; yet in a study of parental expectations, mothers of 11-month-old infants consistently overestimated their boys’ physical skills and underestimated those of their daughters. The expectations that boys will walk earlier may have to do with physical size, since boys tend to be heavier and taller than girls by around six months.
Takeaway tip: Build up your baby’s muscles by giving your little guy or gal plenty of tummy time in the early months — and making sure your tot doesn’t spend too much time confined to the stroller, car seat, or play yard.
Talking
One milestone that girls and boys do consistently hit at different times is talking — girls start about a month earlier than boys on average, sometime in the first half of the second year. British researchers found that girl babies had significantly larger vocabularies than boys as early as 18 and 24 months. Experts say, however, that gender explains up to only 3 percent of differences in toddlers’ verbal skills, with a child’s exposure to language and his or her environment accounting for at least 50 percent of differences.
Takeaway tip: Moms and dads should talk to and read to their babies often, whether they’re girls or boys.
Potty Training
Girls, hands down, ditch their diapers faster than boys — sometimes a lot faster. While most girls start toilet training anytime from 22 to 30 months, boys can take three months to even a year longer than girls to achieve all of the 28 skills experts say they need to be diaper-free forever — from staying dry for two hours during the day to being able to pull down underpants. Girls, on average, can pee on their own (a big milestone) by 33 months, but it takes until month 37 for boys to get there. The biggest differences between girls and boys: Sitting still for five minutes so they can poop in the potty — on average, girls can do this by the time they’re three and a quarter years old, but boys take around five months longer to learn the skill.
Takeaway tip: Even if your little boy won’t get the hang of potty training until later, bring out the potty around his second birthday and just let him have fun with it. You never know — it may inspire him to beat the statistics.
Source: http://www.hiwamag.com/psychology/girls-and-boys-differences/
Comments
Post a Comment